Our Menus

Sandwich & Party Trays

All party trays are served on or with Artisan Breads & Rolls, condiments, and assorted pickles except where noted. When ordering a Tray please note that some include designated sides while others allow you to choose 2  sides.
These options are below:

Red Skin Potato Salad
Macaroni Salad
Veggie Pasta Salad
Potato Chips
Broccoli Salad
Sesame Noodles
Garden Salad
Caesar Salad
String Bean Salad
Spinach Salad
Raw Veggies & Dip
Greek Pasta Salad
Lettuce & Tomato Tray

All party trays are priced per person, based on 10 people or more. For less than 10 add $1.50 per person; for less than 5, add $2.00 per person. Prices do not include disposables. Paper products are $1.35 per person. Party Trays for 25 people or more will include Deviled Eggs at no extra charge.

When you add paper products and dessert or fruit to any package, Jay’s will provide at no additional charge: assorted can sodas and bottled water.  Just ask for the Big Deal.

Upgraded serving, tableware and beverage options are available.  Just ask.

  • $8.95 Per Person

    Traditional Deli Tray

    The original Jay’s party tray consists of sliced deli meat and cheese platter with gourmet breads, rolls and condiments on…...

    View full Detail »
  • $8.95 Per Person

    Homemade Salad Tray

    Our homestyle salads: Tuna Salad, Chicken Salad, and Egg Salad are served with an assortment of gourmet breads and rolls…...

    View full Detail »
  • $9.95 Per Person

    Gyro Platter

    Lamb shwarma, warm pita, lettuce, tomato, onion, and Tzatziki sauce. Includes two sides.$9.95 per person designated sides...

    View full Detail »
  • $17.95 Per Person

    Gourmet Sandwich Tray

    An upscale elegant variety of freshly prepared foods on European Style gourmet breads and rolls. Sandwiches include: Jumbo Lump Crab…...

    View full Detail »
  • $14.75 Per Person

    Lombard Street Party

    Half pound sandwiches from a real Jewish Style Deli: Lean Corned beef, Brisket, Pastrami, Turkey and Roast Beef. Served with…...

    View full Detail »
  • $11.75Per Person

    Hail Caesar

    Premade chicken Caesar wraps (colorful flour tortillas filled with sliced grilled chicken breast, Caesar salad, dressing and parmesan cheese). Served…...

    View full Detail »
  • $12.95Per Person

    Panini Platter

    Signature Panini Sandwiches made on fresh sourdough, grilled to a crisp golden finish. Served on a platter with side dishes…...

    View full Detail »
  • $5.50For Two

    Mini sandwiches

    Tuna salad, chicken salad, roasted turkey, ham & cheese, roast beef, corned beef, power house veggie. Two for $5.50 Two…...

    View full Detail »
  • $5.50For Two

    Assorted Sliders

    Cheeseburger, crispy buffalo chicken and ranch, cheesesteak, grilled chicken and bacon with honey mustard, grilled vegetable. Two for $5.50 Please…...

    View full Detail »